Roy Keane is known for his no-nonsense punditry style that cuts through the waffle and cliches that are often present in football analysis. He is respected for his ability to deliver his verdicts in a clear and concise manner, and he is not afraid to set the agenda with his comments. In this section, we will look at five of Roy Keane’s best punditry moments, where he has made some of his most memorable and impactful statements.
Five of Roy Keane’s best punditry moments
- Comparing Erling Haaland’s all-round game to a League Two player Roy Keane’s criticism of Erling Haaland’s all-round game was controversial, but it proved that he is not afraid to call out even the best players in the world. Keane’s comments went viral, and even Pep Guardiola felt the need to defend Haaland’s game in a press conference. Keane’s criticism showed that to him, there are no sacred cows in football, and everyone has things they can improve on.
- Savaging the ‘small club’ mentality at Manchester United Keane’s declaration that Erik ten Hag’s team played like a small club during their 2-2 draw with Liverpool struck a chord with many Manchester United fans. Keane has been one of the most acerbic critics of United’s decline in standards since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. His comments, along with those of his ex-United teammate Gary Neville, would provide the perfect soundtrack for a montage of United’s low moments in that time.
- Blasting David de Gea’s performance against Tottenham Keane’s criticism of David de Gea’s performance against Tottenham in June 2020 was one of his most memorable rants. He said he would have been swinging punches at the goalkeeper at half-time and wouldn’t even let him on the bus. Keane’s comments were indicative of his high standards as a former Manchester United captain and seven-time Premier League winner.
- Criticizing the United midfield under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer Keane’s criticism of the United midfield under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer was scathing. He said that if fans thought players like Fred, Scott McTominay, and Nemanja Matic could get United back to winning league titles, they were living in cuckoo land. Keane’s comments were a reflection of his frustration with United’s decline in standards since his playing days.
- Questioning Bruno Fernandes’ worthiness to wear the United armband Keane’s comments on Bruno Fernandes and his worthiness to wear the United armband were controversial. He said that Fernandes was the opposite of what he would want in a captain, citing his whinging, moaning, and constant arm-throwing. Keane’s comments were indicative of his belief in the importance of high standards and professionalism in football.
In conclusion, Roy Keane’s punditry style may not be to everyone’s taste, but his usually cutting remarks don’t hold anything back and set the agenda. His ability to call out even the best players and teams in the world, along with his high standards and professionalism, make him a valuable addition to Sky Sports’ Premier League coverage and ITV’s big tournament line-up.